When Asset Management Companies launch new investment schemes, they do so through NFO (New Fund Offers). These NFOs come in two main types: open-ended and closed-ended. Open-ended NFOs allow investors to buy and sell units anytime after the initial offer period ends, providing flexibility and liquidity. Closed-ended NFOs, on the other hand, have a fixed number of units available only during the offer period and come with a predetermined maturity date. Understanding the difference between these two structures helps investors choose the right option based on their financial goals and liquidity needs. In this article, we will explore the key features, advantages, disadvantages, and open ended NFO vs closed ended NFO difference.
What is an open ended NFO?
An open-ended NFO (New Fund Offer) allows investors to subscribe to a new mutual fund scheme, which will keep accepting investments after the NFO period ends. The fund becomes an open-ended mutual fund after the NFO period ends because investors can purchase or sell their units whenever they want at the current Net Asset Value (NAV). There is no restriction on the number of units that can be issued, making it highly flexible for investors seeking liquidity and continuous entry-exit options.
Pros and cons of open ended NFO
Pros |
Cons |
High liquidity allows investors to redeem units anytime after NFO period. |
Frequent withdrawals by investors may lead to lower overall returns. |
No fixed tenure provides flexibility in investment duration. |
Active fund management required can increase operational costs. |
Units bought and sold at transparent NAV pricing. |
NAV volatility due to market fluctuations can affect short-term returns. |
Continuous investment opportunity through SIPs or lump sum. |
Large-scale redemptions may impact fund stability and performance. |
Suitable for investors prioritising easy access to funds. |
May not be ideal for disciplined long-term wealth building. |
What are closed ended NFO?
A Closed Ended NFO is a New Fund Offer where investors can invest only during the initial subscription period. After that, the scheme remains locked for a fixed tenure. Redemption is generally allowed only after maturity, although units may be listed on stock exchanges for trading. Investors can exit the scheme by selling units on stock exchanges where they are listed, but liquidity may be limited. These NFOs are suitable for long-term investors who can commit funds for the entire investment period.
Pros and cons of closed ended NFO
Following are the pros and cons of open ended NFO vs close ended NFO.
Pros |
Cons |
Fixed investment period encourages disciplined long-term investing. |
Limited liquidity as units can only be sold on stock exchanges. |
Fund managers can implement long-term strategies without redemption pressure. |
Investors can enter only during the NFO period, no flexibility later. |
Units may trade at premium or discount, creating potential value opportunities. |
Market prices can differ significantly from NAV affecting exit value. |
Ideal for investors with specific long-term financial goals. |
Performance locked in for entire tenure, affected by market cycles. |
Stable corpus allows better portfolio management and planning. |
Exit before maturity may involve selling at unfavourable prices. |
Difference between open-ended and closed-ended NFO
The table below highlights the difference between Open ended NFO vs Close ended NFO:
Comparison Basis |
Open-ended NFO |
Closed-ended NFO |
Definition |
NFO for schemes that continuously offer units to investors after NFO closes. |
NFO for schemes offering units only during the initial offer period. |
Subscription |
Open for subscription throughout the year after NFO ends. |
Available only during the specific NFO period. |
Investment Options |
Can invest through SIP or lump sum after NFO. |
Only lump sum investment during NFO period. |
Transaction Execution |
Executed at NAV calculated at end of trading day. |
Traded on stock exchanges with real-time pricing. |
Maturity Period |
No fixed maturity period. |
Fixed maturity period, typically 3 to 5 years. |
Liquidity |
High liquidity, units redeemable anytime at NAV. |
Limited liquidity, depends on stock market availability. |
Corpus Size |
Variable corpus changes with subscriptions and redemptions. |
Fixed corpus determined during NFO. |
Price Determination |
Based on Net Asset Value (NAV). |
Based on market demand and supply. |
Stock Exchange Listing |
Not listed on stock exchanges. |
Listed and traded on stock exchanges. |
Fund Manager Control |
Limited control due to redemption pressures. |
Complete control with stable asset base. |
Choosing between open-ended and close-ended funds
Open-ended funds may be considered if:
Access to liquidity is important to you.
You prefer the ability to purchase or redeem units at the prevailing NAV.
You value flexibility to make adjustments to your portfolio over time.
You are considering investment routes such as SIPs or withdrawal options like SWPs.
Close-ended funds may be considered if:
You are comfortable investing for a predetermined duration.
Immediate liquidity is not a primary requirement.
Your investment horizon is medium to long term.
You are open to a fixed-tenure investment structure.
Conclusion
Different types of NFOs provide distinct investment solutions that meet the different requirements of investors. Investors who require immediate access to their funds may choose open-ended NFOs because these NFOs deliver flexible investment options and continuous access to their funds. Investors who want to maintain their investments over an extended period should consider closed-ended NFOs. They provide consistent fund management but restrict their ability to sell shares during the designated investment period. You should select your investment option based on your financial objectives, your anticipated investment timeframe and your need for liquid cash. You can make better investment choices when you understand these differences.
FAQs on open ended vs closed ended NFO
-
Which is better, open-ended or closed-ended NFO?
There is no best option. Open-ended NFOs may suit investors who want flexibility, while closed-ended NFOs may suit those with a fixed long-term plan.
-
Is SIP possible in closed-ended NFO?
No, SIP (Systematic Investment Plan) is not available in closed-ended NFOs. These schemes accept only lump sum investments during the NFO period. After the NFO closes, no further investments are allowed.
-
How are IDCWs distributed in open-ended and closed-ended NFO?
IDCW (Income Distribution cum Capital Withdrawal) in both types is distributed periodically as per the scheme's policy, monthly, quarterly, or annually. The distribution frequency and terms are specified in the offer document during the NFO.
-
Can Open-ended NFO be redeemed?
Yes, open-ended NFO units can be redeemed after the offer period at the applicable NAV.
-
Which NFOs are open ended?
Equity, debt, and hybrid schemes that allow continuous subscription and redemption after launch are open-ended NFOs.
FOR EXISTING POLICY
FOR NEW POLICY